Time’s up for the ninth Doctor, as Hagan explains why nine is really none, how this episode fucks up the continuity of not one, but two shows, how English politics DON’T work and how the hell we ended up with farting aliens, anyway.
While I agree with most of the things Diamanda pulls up, I forcefully disagree witha few things:
(…)
Charley Parkhurst, the famous pregnant “male” was a post-op transgendered woman. By a Biologist’s definition, as Charley kept his ovaries and uterus, and was born in a female body, Charley was female. See, if you actually got a male pregnant (fuck knows how that’d work without a uterus), and he did not die from the invading organism in his body as his immune system went haywire, his back would break from the stress put on it. No seriously. Before anyone speaks of sea horses, I want to start off with saying the male sea horse carries the fertilised eggs in a pouch, and fish cannot be compared to mammals on this point. Mammals are placental. Our config is completely different from egg-layers, especially those who do not even have chromosomatically fixed sexes. Hate to burst your yaoi-bubble, gals, but men CANNOT get pregnant. At least not men who started as men and went through gestation and puberty as men.
I think that you misunderstood the point that Hagan was making in this regard. By her (more humanitarian) definition, the true gender of a person is the one as which the person identifies. The gender as defined by the self-image and mental orientation takes precedence over the physical circumstances of birth. Going by this definition (with which I tend to agree), Charley Parkhurst has always been a man. He just had the bad luck of having been born with the wrong physical characteristics.
I think that you misunderstood the point that Hagan was making in this regard. By her (more humanitarian) definition, the true gender of a person is the one as which the person identifies. The gender as defined by the self-image and mental orientation takes precedence over the physical circumstances of birth. Going by this definition (with which I tend to agree), Charley Parkhurst has always been a man. He just had the bad luck of having been born with the wrong physical characteristics.
Edit: Diamanda has just clarified via Twitter. Quotes:
A minion-run blog dedicated to Diamanda Hagan, mistress of Haganistan.
Fanworks and expressions of admiration to the mistress welcome. Views expressed in this blog are not necessarily the same as Hagans, and should not be taken as official statements.